gasexchange

Posts tagged Anesthesiology.

The Unseen Anaesthetist

A grim discontent with healthcare in many Western countries is intensifying, exposing cracks in a strained system.

The recent murder of a US health insurance CEO, along with the dark wave of public sympathy for the assailant, warns us that health system inequity and failure may culminate in extreme ways.

Australia faces its own challenges: escalating medical costs and burdened public and private hospitals, even as international healthcare corporations post record profits. The growing corporatisation of healthcare, driven by insurance companies and hospital conglomerates, is a concerning glimpse of one possible future for medical care. A significant portion of Australian healthcare funding now leaves our shores for these international corporations and their shareholders.

Yet media coverage presents an unbalanced narrative. While corporate healthcare profits receive measured reporting, medical practitioners face scrutiny and criticism, frequently without evidence. I wrote the piece below in response to a two-year media campaign suggesting widespread billing fraud among Australian doctors, particularly anaesthetists and surgeons. Much of this reporting revealed misunderstandings of the health system and medical billing while ignoring how such stories serve corporate healthcare interests, even as the same corporations encourage attacks on doctors from the sidelines.

I submitted this op-ed to several Australian media outlets, but it remains unpublished. I'm sharing it here to contribute to a balanced understanding of the role of medical professionals in Australian healthcare.

Read more...

Opioid-free, AF anaesthesia and LMA atelectasis

Three interesting recent studies looking at specific choices around anaesthetic technique. In the Canadian Journal of Anesthesia, da Silveira reviews the benefits of opioid-free laparoscopic surgery; in the Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia, Ford goes deep on the pros and cons of different anaesthetic techniques for AF ablation procedures; and finally in the JCA, Liu reports on a single-centre RCT investigating the beneficial effects of LMAs on atelectasis.

Opioid-Free Laparoscopic Surgery: Less Nausea, Similar Pain Control

An interesting meta-analysis from da Silveira et al. explores whether we can effectively manage minimally invasive abdominal surgery without using opioids - an important question given how common opioid-related side effects are.

This was a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis of 26 randomised controlled trials, including 2,025 patients. The researchers specifically compared opioid-free versus opioid-containing anesthesia in minimally invasive abdominal surgeries. They were particularly interested in looking at side effects like PONV and bradycardia, as well as pain control and recovery times.

The results were quite interesting. The authors found that opioid-free anaesthesia:

  • Reduced PONV by 45% (from 24% to 13% / RR CI 0.40 to 0.74).
  • Led to slightly lower immediate postoperative pain scores (though not clinically significant).
  • Required less postoperative opioid use in the first 2 hours.
  • Showed no difference in recovery room length of stay.
  • Showed no increase in bradycardia, a previously noted concern when using intraoperative dexmedetomidine.

Read more...

Does a GA CS increase PPD risk? Plus LMA studies & COVID vaccine optimism

GA caesarean section & post-partum depression

This large study (Guglielminotti 2020) of 428,204 New York caesarean section records (2006-2013), including 34,356 general anaesthetics (8%), investigated the association between mode of anaesthesia and post-partum depression (PPD). Other studies have shown an association between caesarean section (emergency > elective) and PPD. (Sun 2021, Xu 2017, and others), though this is the first to look specifically at general anaesthesia as a PPD risk factor.

Guglielminotti and Li found that general anaesthesia increased the odds of severe PPD by 54% (aOR 1.54, 1.21-1.95), and suicidal ideation by a massive 91% (aOR 1.91, 1.12-3.25), though not a significant increase in anxiety or PTSD.

The researchers discuss many potential causative factors, particularly known associations between GA CS & poor pain control, and subsequent pain & PPD – while also acknowledging the obvious potential for confounders. Of note patients receiving GA were older, more often non-Caucasian, had more co-morbidities, neonatal complexity, and lower socio-economic levels – also all independently associated with PPD risk.

In order to quantify the potential confounding contribution of emergency vs elective status, the researchers employed the novel E value:

To assess the impact of emergent cesarean delivery on our results, we calculated the E value associated with the aOR for the risk of PPD and suicidality. This relatively new metric takes into consideration 2 associations: (1) that between the confounder (emergent cesarean delivery) and the outcome (PPD); and (2) the association between the confounder (emergent cesarean delivery) and the exposure (general anesthesia).

An E value of 1.7 for the unmeasured confounder emergent cesarean delivery indicates that to explain away the association between general anesthesia and depression, either: (1) emergent cesarean delivery increases the risk of depression by at least 70%; or (2) emergent cesarean delivery is at least 70% more prevalent among general anesthesia than among neuraxial anesthesia. Either association is clinically plausible.

Keep it in perspective...

We already know that general anaesthesia for CS is suboptimal: it compromises both maternal experience and safety, but it should (hopefully) only ever be a chosen mode of anaesthesia when there is a true contraindication to regional anaesthesia – even at the modestly-high 8% GA rate among this New York cohort.

Looking at it from the other end, bear in mind that the modestly-faster time-to-incision for GA over regional is also of questionable neonatal benefit.

The take-home:

Just another reason to avoid GA CS when possible – but you already knew that, right?

"...general anesthesia is a potentially modifiable risk factor for PPD. This finding provides further supporting evidence favoring neuraxial over general anesthesia in cesarean delivery whenever possible."

Supraglottic airway training and manikins

Interesting prospective simulation & equipment study by way of the University of Freiburg. Schmutz et al. investigated how effective five different second generation supraglottic airway devices (SADs) performed in two common airway manikins: the TruCorp AirSim® and the crowd favourite, Laerdal's Resusci Anne® Airway Trainer™.

While ventilation was achieved in all SAD-manikin combinations, the Resusci Anne® Airway Trainer™ was associated with better and more consistent performance for SAD position, participant subjective assessment and ease of gastric tube insertion for most of the SADs. The TruCorp AirSim® did however achieve better leak pressures across most of the SADs (LMA® Supreme™, Ambu® AuraGain™, i-gel®, KOO™-SGA & LTS-D™).

But then, what are the implications for airway simulation training? The researchers correctly note that:

The most important quality of a manikin is the ability to simulate the real-world conditions and thus to give the trainee an authentic feedback.

The bottom line for SAD manikins?

While considering how manikin choice and SAD availability match with your aims for simulation training, the bigger picture is that the primary goal of any manikin-SAD coupling is real-life fidelity – and for that reason, participant subjective assessment is king. And so in this study at least, the Resusci Anne® Airway Trainer™ wins.

Read on for head rotation with LMAs & COVID vaccine persistence...

PONV, Perioperative Bleeding Aids & Surgery Timing After COVID

A big PONV meta-analysis

Interesting Cochrane meta-analysis looking at PONV prophylaxis from German (Weibel et al. 2021) that included almost 100,000 study participants across 585 trials. Interesting not so much because it confirms much of what we already new (or assumed, based on our common PONV prophylaxis drug choices), but because it reassures us that side-effects from commonly used PONV drugs are low to non-existent.

PONV Takeaway:

Granisetron is probably the best single-agent or in combination with other agents because of it's efficacy (better than ondansetron), low-cost, long duration, and absent side-effects.

A cognitive aid to better manage perioperative bleeding

Although the benefits of cognitive aids to many areas of anaesthesia are well established, our resistance to using decision support tools persists. Whether due to misplaced perceptions of losing autonomy or Dunning Kruger-adjacent inflated belief in our ability to perform under pressure, is unclear.

In Anaesthesia, Kataife et al. (2021) describe a cognitive aid for better managing perioperative haemorrhage, the Haemostasis Traffic Light algorithm. Using a simulation-based RCT across two centres (University Hospital Zurich & The Italian Hospital of Buenos Aires, N=84), they showed that using the HTL improved case solutions (OR 7.23, 3.82-13.68), quickened therapeutic decisions, (HR 1.97, 1.18-3.29), improved therapeutic confidence, (OR 4.31, 1.67-11.11) and reduced workload perception.

The aim of the HTL is to improve both situational awareness and decision making, by integrating clinical judgement and point-of-care testing (ROTEM) within an accessible, structured algorithm.

Haemostasis Traffic Light takeaway:

Kataife's study again shows the benefit of cognitive aids, particularly in critical, time-sensitive situations. The anaesthesia and critical care community's historical resistance to decision-support tools requires challenge.

Read on for timing of surgery after COVID infection...

A & A Case Reports now indexed by metajournal

Anesthesia and Analgesia's companion journal Anesthesia and Analgesia Case Reports is now indexed by metajournal, after being requested by our users.

A & A Case Reports has only been around since October 2013, after spinning off from the prestigious Anesthesia & Analgesia. It is now a standalone publication "...devoted exclusively to publishing cases that are educational and unusual."

A & A Case Reports now indexed by metajournal

You can jump in a browse the latest from A & A Case Reports among our indexed journals.

UPDATE:

Anesthesia & Analgesia has now evolved A & A Case Reports into A & A Practice – naturally, also indexed by metajournal!

Want more great medical articles?

Keep up to date with a free trial of metajournal, personalized for your practice.
1,704,841 articles already indexed!

We guarantee your privacy. Your email address will not be shared.