The Clinical journal of pain
-
The goal of this study was to assess clinical consensus regarding whether myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) is a legitimate and distinct diagnosis as well as the signs and symptoms characterizing MPS. ⋯ There was general agreement across specialties that MPS is a legitimate diagnosis distinct from fibromyalgia. There was a high level of agreement regarding the signs and symptoms essential or associated with a diagnosis of MPS. Differences across specialties are discussed. This survey provides a first step toward the development of consensus-based diagnostic criteria for MPS, which can then be validated empirically.
-
Meta-analysis (MA) is the application of quantitative techniques for the purposes of summarizing data from individual studies. This type of review has many advantages over traditional reviews. However, different investigators performing MAs on the same data set have reached different conclusions. These reliability problems have been attributed to differences in the quality of the implemented meta-analytic procedures. We, therefore, examined the chronic pain treatment meta-analytic literature for MA procedure quality and for the consistency of conclusions. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, OUTCOME MEASURES: Chronic pain treatment MAs were isolated according to inclusion/exclusion criteria. Data from these MAs were abstracted into structured tables. Table format reflected eight meta-analytic procedures identified previously as being important to MA implementation quality. These were: adequacy of retrieval, publication bias, inclusion/exclusion criteria, abstraction of data, quality, homogeneity/heterogeneity, independence, and statistical versus clinical interpretation. Each meta-analytic procedure was then independently rated by two raters. Rating results were then analyzed by procedure for each individual MA for percentage scores out of 100%, and mean scores. For MAs addressing the same topic area (pain facility treatment, antidepressant treatment, manipulation treatment) direction of effect size was noted. Mean effect sizes were calculated for these subgroups. ⋯ Some meta-analytic procedures could be interpreted to be implemented inadequately in some chronic pain treatment MAs. There is wide variability between individual chronic pain treatment MAs on adequacy of implementation of these procedures. However, the effect sizes of the different MA subgroups demonstrated consistency. This finding indicates that for these MA subgroups, MA results are consistent between authors. In addition, chronic pain MAs, as compared with other groups of MAs, appear to address some of the procedures in a more adequate fashion. Future chronic pain MAs should concentrate on improving the quality of their methods with particular emphasis on the above four procedures. Because of potential validity problems with these results, these data cannot and should not be used to make administrative decisions about previous MAs.
-
Comparative Study
Comorbid fibromyalgia accounts for reduced fecundity in women with myofascial face pain.
This study examined factors related to reduced fecundity among women with myofascial face pain (MFP) arising from hypotheses concerning the role of neurohormonal factors in MFP and associated conditions. ⋯ Reduced fecundity in women with MFP is restricted to those who self-report a history of fibromyalgia. Possible mechanisms for reduced fecundity in fibromyalgia are discussed. These findings highlight the need to screen for widespread pain among women with regional myofascial pain syndromes.
-
The goal of this study was to examine whether body activity such as postural, trunk, and limb movements may be potential pain cues in preterm infants. ⋯ Some extensor movements seemed to be distress signals, whereas tremors, startles, and twitches were not related to discomfort during the observation period. These behaviors may differ qualitatively during longer lasting tissue invasive events. The results of this study indicate the need for more in-depth study of patterns of motor activity in preterm infants over longer observation periods to evaluate potential signs of stress and pain in babies undergoing NICU medical care.
-
Considerable research indicates that both high levels of anxiety and female sex are associated with increased sensitivity to experimental pain and greater experience of clinical pain. In general, however, previous research has not investigated the joint effects of sex and anxiety on pain responses. A single previous laboratory-based study indicated that anxiety was inversely related to pain thresholds among men but not among women. The present study examined the relation between pain-related anxiety and adjustment to chronic pain in a sex-dependent manner. ⋯ Results generally supported the previous laboratory-based finding indicating that an inverse relation between anxiety and adjustment to chronic pain was present only among male patients. Although male patients with high pain-related anxiety reported greater pain severity, greater interference of pain, and lower levels of daily activity than male patients with low anxiety, this effect was not present among female patients. Moreover, the effects of pain-related anxiety on adjustment to chronic pain were not attributable to either hypervigilance or use of passive coping strategies. Potential explanations and implications for the present findings are discussed.