Diving Hyperb Med
-
Unestablished indications are conditions in which systematic clinical use of hyperbaric oxygen treatment (HBOT) is not supported by adequate proof of benefit. HBOT is vulnerable to use in many such conditions for various reasons, perhaps the most important being that a placebo or participation effect may create an impression of efficacy. The systematic use of HBOT in unestablished indications raises ethical concerns about provision of misleading information, giving false hope, and taking payment for therapy of doubtful benefit. ⋯ Advocates for HBOT in chronic brain injury claim that the sham treatments (usually 1.3 ATA pressure exposure whilst air breathing) in the blinded trials are actually active treatments; however, the same dose of oxygen can be achieved at 1 ATA breathing 27% oxygen. To counter this argument, advocates also claim that the extra 0.3 ATA of pressure is somehow independently beneficial, but this notion has limited biological plausibility and there is little supporting evidence. Chronic brain injuries remain unestablished indications at this time and, in our opinion, should not be systematically treated with HBOT.
-
Case Reports
Two fatal cases of immersion pulmonary oedema - using dive accident investigation to assist the forensic pathologist.
Immersion pulmonary oedema (IPE) is being increasingly recognized in swimmers, snorkellers and scuba divers presenting with acute symptoms of respiratory distress following immersion, but fatal case reports are uncommon. We report two fatal cases of probable IPE in middle-aged women, one whilst snorkelling and the other associated with a scuba dive. In the snorkeller's case, an episode of exercise-related chest tightness and shortness of breath that occurred 10 months previously was investigated but this proved negative, and she was on no medications. ⋯ The scuba diver had suffered several previous episodes of severe shortness of breath following dives, one being so severe it led to cyanosis and impaired consciousness. At inquest, the pathologist's diagnosis was given as drowning and IPE was not mentioned. Expert input from doctors trained in diving medicine should be compulsory in the investigation of diving deaths, and forensic pathologists should be properly trained in and have guidelines for the conduct of post-immersion and post-diving autopsies.
-
Observational Study
Neuron-specific enolase and S100B protein levels in recreational scuba divers with neurological decompression sickness.
Neuron-specific enolase (NSE) and S100B protein are brain-origin proteins commonly described to assess the presence and severity of neurological injury. To date, there are limited data examining the influence of scuba diving on these biomarkers, particularly when symptoms of decompression sickness (DCS) occur. The purpose of this controlled study was to determine whether these serum neurochemical markers could be used as 1) indicators of neurological DCS and 2) predictors of incomplete recovery. ⋯ Early determination of NSE was found to be useful for the diagnosis of neurological DCS with a high specificity. However, its clinical applicability in decision making for determining treatment as well as its prognostic value remains to be established. Reliability of S100B protein was not demonstrated in the present study.