Der Anaesthesist
-
Randomized Controlled Trial Multicenter Study
[The design of the VISEP trial. Critical appraisal].
The survey transcript of the VISEP interventional trial "Prospective randomized multicenter study on the influence of colloid vs crystalloid volume resuscitation and of intensive vs conventional insulin therapy on outcome in patients with severe sepsis and septic shock" [Clinical trials.gov. identifier: NCT00135473; study start April 2003] comprises, according to the data of the year 2003, methodological shortcomings which challenge a priori the study design and thus the resolution of the purpose of the study, i.e., "determination of the influence of the studied volume and insulin interventions on morbidity and mortality of patients with severe sepsis and septic shock". The most important points of criticism are: 1. A volume therapy with exclusively crystalloids or colloids with the chosen colloid hyperoncotic, hyperchloremic HES solution (10% hydroxyethyl starch: 10% Hemohes) or the crystalloid solution with high lactate content (Sterofundin) is neither acceptable nor practicable, even if only due to exceeding the maximum dosage as recommended by the manufacturer. 2. ⋯ It is doubtful whether an intensified insulin therapy (Actrapid) can be successful if insulin is administered simultaneously with iatrogenic hyperglycemia as a result of lactate influx. Due to these flaws in the design of the VISEP trial, the only consequence can be that the results of the survey are unusable, especially with regard to the point "HES and kidney function". Thus, any further advance presentations and interpretations should be shelved in expectation of the authors' publication of all the data, in order to begin further discussions including the flaws in study design listed here.
-
Randomized Controlled Trial
[Dolasetron and shivering. A prospective randomized placebo-controlled pharmaco-economic evaluation].
Forced by the current economical situation, German hospitals have to reconsider their clinical productivity. When caregivers introduce new therapeutic concepts medical quality should either be improved without increasing costs or when reducing costs medical quality should be maintained. In the surgical field postoperative shivering reduces both patient comfort and medical quality. We therefore investigated the clinical pathway prevention of shivering with dolasetron in a prospective, randomized, placebo-controlled analysis of cost-effectiveness. ⋯ The optimization of the clinical process and medical quality induced by a prophylaxis against shivering and postoperative nausea and vomiting compensates for the increased use of pharmaceutical resources in our setting.