J Gynecol Obst Bio R
-
J Gynecol Obst Bio R · Apr 2002
Review[Audits and confidential enquiry: thoughts on the technique used by the French National Committee for the reduction of maternal deaths].
This study demonstrates the need for a confidential approach to medial information when the objective is to improve medical practices, as was the goal of the French National Committee for the reduction of maternal deaths. This approach is the exact opposite of a litigation where the goal is to determine "guilt". ⋯ We review here similar actions taken to reduce other types of medical accidents such as anesthesia deaths. The confidential approach has been found to be pertinent in the perinatal audit conducted in the Seine-Saint-Denis region, including all fetal and neonatal deaths, that has shown measurable reduction in the number of fetal deaths.
-
J Gynecol Obst Bio R · Feb 2002
Review[Potential role of prenatal care in reducing maternal and perinatal mortality in sub-Saharan Africa].
Prenatal care has been implemented in developing countries according to the same mode as applied in industrialized countries without considering its real effectiveness in reducing maternal and neonatal mortality. Several recent studies suggest that the goals should be revisited in order to implement a program of prenatal care based on real scientific evidence. Based on the current literature, we propose a potentially effective content for prenatal care adapted to the context of developing countries. ⋯ The purpose of these consultations would be: 1) to screen for three major risk factors, which, when recognized, lead to specific action: uterine, scare, malpresentation, premature rupture of the membranes; 2) to prevent and/or detect (and treat) specific complications of pregnancy: hypertension, infection (malaria, venereal disease, HIV, tetanus, urinary tract infection); anemia and trace element deficiencies, gestational diabetes mellitus; 3) to provide counseling, support and information for pregnant women and their families (including the partner) concerning: severe signs and symptoms of pregnancy and delivery, community organization of emergency transfer, delivery planning. These potentially effective actions can only have a real public health impact if implemented within an organized maternal health system with a functional network of delivery units, if truly quality care is given, and if the relationships between health care providers and the population are based on mutual respect. Sub-Saharan African women use prenatal care extensively when it is accessible; this opportunity must be used to implement evidence-based actions with appropriate and realistic goals.
-
How far providing neonatal intensive care to extremely low birth weight infants is appropriate is still a highly controversial issue. Decision making when a poor prognosis has been established may be facilitated by consensus based recommendations and rigorous procedures. In the very majority of situations, the provision of intensive care is advocated at birth a priori. ⋯ In any case, an ethical policy focused on each infant's best interest is justified, while the adoption of a systematic, gestational age or birth weight based restriction of access to intensive care may not be acceptable in most countries. Rigorous criteria must be fulfilled for end of life decision making and procedures. Continuous assistance to the patient and to the parents is key determinant.
-
Since 1996, maternal mortality is registered as part of a permanent confidential inquiry in France. The National Committee has studied all cases recorded to assess the cause of death and the avoidable obstetrical complications involved. Recommendations are proposed. ⋯ The deaths due to amniotic fluid embolism were not considered avoidable. This mortality stemmed from substandard care, delayed treatment, missed diagnosis, and professional errors. Clinical recommendations are proposed for post partum hemorrhage, pre-eclampsia and eclampsia, prevention of maternal infection, and thromboembolism prophylaxy.
-
Anesthesia-related mortality in France is being studied in a survey that began in 1996 using the United Kingdom survey as a model. We describe here the deaths reported in these two surveys and discuss the management strategies involved. ⋯ The methodology of the French maternal mortality survey provides data enabling the institution of preventive measures. Specific actions, some of which would require legislation, are proposed to improve maternal safety.