• Florian Geiger, Monique Zimmermann-Stenzel, Christian Heisel, Burkhard Lehner, and Wolfgang Daecke.
• Orthopaedic University Hospital, Schlierbacher Landstr 200a, 69118, Heidelberg, Germany. f.geiger@friedrichsheim.de
• Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2007 Dec 1;127(10):959-66.

IntroductionThe aim of the study was to compare the mortality risk and complication rate after operative treatment of pertrochanteric fractures with primary arthroplasty, dynamic hip screw (DHS) or proximal femoral nail (PFN).Patients And MethodsClinical records including X-rays of all patients with trochanteric femoral fractures, except pathologic fractures and a minimum age of 60 years, which were treated between 1992 and 2005 were entered in this retrospective study. Of these 283 patients, 132 were treated by primary arthroplasty, 109 with a DHS and 42 with a PFN. Survival after 1 year and complications, which had to be treated within this period were our main outcome measurement. Influencing cofactors such as age, gender and comorbidities were reduced by multivariate logistic regression analysis.ResultsMortality was significantly influenced by age, gender and amount of comorbidities but not by fracture classification. Primary hip arthroplasty did not bear a higher 1-year mortality risk than osteosynthesis in a multiple regression analysis. The main complication with DHS and PFN were cutting out of the hip screw and non-union with a revision rate of 12.8%. With the introduction of hemiarthroplasty, the postoperative dislocation rate decreased from 12 to 0%.ConclusionFor stable fractures a dynamic hip screw (DHS) and for unstable fractures a short proximal femoral nail (PFN) can be recommended. The mortality risk of primary cemented arthroplasty did not differ significantly from the other treatment groups and because of its low complication rate it is a viable treatment option for trochanteric fractures if osteoporosis prevents from full weight bearing or if osteoarthritis makes further operations likely. Primary total hip replacement should be handled with care due to its significantly higher dislocation rate compared with hemiarthroplasty especially in unstable fractures.

31 keywords...

hide…